Rose's Turn's sister piano bar in Times Square is far bigger than it looks from its slightly below ground level entrance. It's a loud and jovial mix of young and old, … locals and tourists, and any other pair of opposites you find in the Big Apple.
[link]

Located inside the Carlyle Hotel (which hosts Woody Allen's band regularly), Bemelman's is an upscale piano bar predictably quite different from the rest in this list. … Also predictably, they charge a $20 cover on weekdays and $25 on weekends accompany the performances of the resident pianists.
[link]

The Duplex is as colorful as one would assume from its Christopher Street location in the West Village, operating for over 50 years and recently undergoing renovation … upstairs. Maybe you'll be lucky enough to sing "Sonny and Cher" with one of the folks you see here.
[link]

If you fancy a fancy piano bar with a dress code, this "most elegant gentleman's club of NYC" is the place to go. The crowd tends to be more homogenous (read: gay … middle-age men) than downtown spots, but straight girls, you won't get hit on by hammered NYU boys that way.
[link]

Operating since 1979, this Upper East Side hole-in-the-wall serves a mixed audience, and the singing bartenders and wait staff -- veterans of the stage themselves -- … perform an equally mixed collection of songs.
[link]

Marie's is yet another tiny piano bar patronized by the gay community in the village, but it sticks to the proverbial showtune. This one's for the Broadway lovers or … drunk incoherent haters whose ears are already ringing.
[link]